It is currently Thu Oct 18, 2018 9:37 pm

Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 1 post ] 
Author Message
 Post subject: Reports: Modernising Child Protection in New Zealand
PostPosted: Thu Sep 27, 2018 7:57 pm 
User avatar

Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 8:48 am
Posts: 6811
Location: Oslo

Reports: Modernising Child Protection in New Zealand

Ilan Katz, Natasha Cortis, Aron Shlonsky and Robyn Mildon:
Modernising Child Protection in New Zealand: Learning from system reforms in other jurisdictions
Families Commission - Kōmihana ā Whānau, May 2016

"This report outlines some key issues for child protection systems, based on a review of approaches and reforms in England, the United States, Canada (Ontario), Norway and Australia (New South Wales). These jurisdictions were selected as being similar to New Zealand in their basic approach to child protection but also to include one jurisdiction which offers a contrasting approach. Systems in the English-speaking jurisdictions are all ‘child protection’ oriented or ‘residual’. In these systems child protection is mainly a response to children who have been maltreated or who are at signi cant risk of maltreatment. The systems therefore focus on assessment, surveillance and child removal. In contrast, the Norwegian system is a ‘family support’ system which intervenes in a wider range of family issues and is focused on supporting families in the community. This paper is based on a search of peer-reviewed and ‘grey literature’ and compares jurisdictions with New Zealand."

The report includes a fair amount of statistics.

What the report relates about the Norwegian child protection system is entirely based on official information. It focuses a lot on the formal organisation of the system.


"The underlying principle of the system is to promote the best interests of the child. Filial bonds are considered a resource. Reflecting the family support focus and the provision of accessible services, parents frequently initiate contact with the Child Welfare Service. Parents are an important source of notification (15.8%) (Kojan & Lonne, 2012). To remove a child, child welfare services require parental consent or approval from the independent County Committee for Social Affairs."

The experience of many thousands of Norwegian families shows each of these statements to be a total misrepresentation of reality.

"Although the Norwegian system responds to a wider variety of needs than in Australia, including youth justice and mental health, the number of investigations per 1000 children is lower (27.2 in 2009 compared with 40.2 in Australia). Also, a higher proportion of investigations result in substantiated cases (50.2% compared with
33.6% in Australia) (Kojan & Lonne, 2012)."

That a higher proportion investigated is taken up as cases does not mean that the allegations are substantiated. It means that they are claimed to be, made out to be. Norwegian CPS is far from truthful in what it says, be it about the individual family or about the way they fit aspects of cases into statistics.


Poor New Zealand, being recommended to try and learn from Norway – from what Norwegian CPS pretends to be. I remember New Zealanders as practical, rather down-to-earth, sceptical about foreign pretensions and "elegance". I wish they would look through the nonsense of Norway.
    In May 2016, the date of this report, there had recently been demonstrations in Norway against the child protection agency, and more followed. There had been one in December 2015, there were some in 2017, and particularly January through June 2016 there were also demonstrations; on 16 April people demonstrated against Norwegian CPS in many cities and places in about 20 countries around the world, with altogether many thousand protesters. There was even a small but supportive one in Hamilton, Waikato! People knew then, particularly but not exclusively through the Bodnariu case, that all that our authorities and the CPS people themselves claim for our CPS is untrue.

Demonstrations abroad against Norwegian child protection (CPS) – Barnevernet
Welcome! – to the demonstration in Oslo 16 April 2016
Demonstrations in Norway apropos ditto abroad
Demonstration in Oslo on Saturday 19 August 2017
Resounding victory for the child protection demonstrators!
Demonstration in Oslo December 5th (2015)!
Demonstrations against Norwegian child protection in many cities on 30 May 2015.
The child protection system will also be a theme in the European Union on 2 June
European demonstrations against the Norwegian child protection agency

The demonstration against the CPS in Oslo 13 December 2013


Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 1 post ] 

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Theme designed by © 2008
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
All times are UTC [ DST ]